San Francisco mayor Gavin Newsome recently followed his ban of plastic grocery bags with a ban on plastic-bottled water. No city funds can be spent on it, and no bottled water can be sold on city-owned property. City residents who sign an online pledge not to buy plastic-bottled water at stores can get a free stainless steel container from the city. Great move. Of course, Newsome has the support of a generally conscientious city. Elsewhere, it’s not always so easy. If you read outside the environmental choir loft, you'll always find people outraged about the interference of local governments and school boards in the public right to be provided at all times with the full free-market smorgasbord of consumer products, including the wasteful, cruddy, and unhealthy. Next, they may fear, San Francisco will levy a tax on cars sold inside city limits that don’t achieve a certain MPG. Then the city might enforce, say, litter laws with the same vigor seen in northern Virginia when it comes to speeders. Well, this is what laws are all about. If enough people and representatives vote for them, they get passed. The San Francisco ban on heinous, wasteful, idiotic plastics is both practical and symbolic, and it will cause no real discomfort.
Keep reusable bags in your car and take them into stores when you shop. Just get in the habit. If you forget, choose a paper bag, or maybe just carry the items out in your bare hands. If you run a store, how about banning plastic bags yourself? Just offer paper.
As for plastic water bottles, here’s part of what Newsome said in Newsweek:
Newsome: The transportation and distribution, developing the plastic for the water bottles, the cost of the water, has a huge environmental and economic impact. As a consequence of the prolific growth in bottled waters, we in the city feel we have a responsibility to address its cost and its environmental impact. We are looking to eliminate completely all of bottled water consumption supported by city money but also to begin an educational campaign to convey the real cost of bottled water, transported half way around the world. We are looking at a marketing campaign showing bottled water compared to a barrel of oil, that shows it takes far more energy to transport the water than the oil.
Newsweek: Representatives from the bottled-water industry say it’s unfair to single out their product. Thousands of food and beverage items come in plastic packaging, they point out—and consumers like having a healthy choice of water, instead of buying drinks containing sugar and calories.
Newsome: Yes, but the difference between bottled water and Diet Coke is that you can’t get Diet Coke from the tap. It’s not like any other bottled liquids. These people are making huge amounts of money selling God’s natural resources. Sorry, we’re not going to be part of it. Our water in San Francisco comes from the Hetch Hetchy [reservoir] and is some of the most pristine water on the planet. Our water is arguably cleaner than a vast majority of the bottled water sold as "pure."
Most of us in this country can get good drinking water from the tap. Those whose water is marginal can filter it, and those who absolutely have to buy it, can at least buy it in large, refillable containers. Newsweek also touched on another part of the problem -- the hundreds of brands of soft drinks, “sport” drinks, and juices sold in plastic bottles. No, you can’t get a Diet Coke or Pepsi out of the tap, so it becomes the responsibility of Coke and Pepsi to find less damaging ways to package their products, maybe someday in biodegradable plastic substitutes like those made by Novamont and Metabolix. Large-scale use of these materials by the soda giants would have a huge positive impact.
Better in the long run, though, is the one-person-one-bottle model. Find a reusable container that you like, and keep it by your side. Stainless steel, plastic, Styrofoam, whatever. Sure, you still might have to buy something in a disposable cup or bottle once in a while, but think what would happen if millions of people cut their disposable container purchases by, say, 80 percent.
Shown here is an assortment of drink powders surrounding a Rubbermaid "chug-mug" with a 20-oz. (600 ml.) capacity. Some of these flavors are pretty good (no worse than Coke or Pepsi or Gatorade or any of the various things we swill all the time; in fact Propel is basically powdered Gatorade), but more to the point, the waste-per-drink is limited to a tiny foil packet.
~ Doug Logan, New Energy Watch
Recent Comments